"There is a person - there is a problem, no person - there is no problem" Who said and the meaning of the statement

2024 Author: Henry Conors | [email protected]. Last modified: 2024-02-12 02:46

Winged expressions, set phrases, turns of speech - all this is found everywhere in our lives. They are full of speech, they are full of movies and radio, television, literature.

It will be interesting to understand who said: "No person - no problem." These words are often put into the mouths of villains, heroes of numerous crime series of one well-known television channel.

Exposure

If you conduct a small survey among the reading population of our country, many will answer that the popular expression first flew out of the mouth of the "Leader of the Peoples" - Comrade Joseph Vissarionovich Stalin (Dzhugashvili). From the history of the Land of the Soviets, it is known for certain that this man was a cruel person, capable of the most extreme measures in relation to "enemies of the people".

Who were they, these "enemies of the people"? According to historians, the leader is veryoften suspected people of conspiracies and betrayals. This kind of incredulity is disturbing in itself. Probably, the person had developed persecution mania - one of the mental disorders. His associates noted that the head of the country had a hard look, suppressed his energy, was suspicious and kept his entourage in fear.

But, being "at the helm" of power, Stalin could afford any actions, fitting them into the framework of political expediency. Finding out the question of who said: "No man - no problem", it is quite realistic to assume that this expression belongs to Joseph Stalin.

Meaning of the statement

It is important to understand the meaning of such a "bold" statement, how could a person even say such a thing.

After all, in those days, death solved all problems: no man - no problems. The black funnel at the entrance during the years of repression caused horror among the population. Arrests, camps, "enemies of the people" are gloomy symbols of the 30s and 40s for the USSR. Historians call the stages of repression "waves". The arrests took place as if by magic of a schizophrenic magician.

Stalin saw enemies everywhere: in the army (talented commanders were shot), in medicine (the famous "doctors' case"). Moreover, among the common people - workers, peasants and intelligentsia, there were a sufficient number of "traitors to Soviet power." Actually, by eliminating people, the "leader of the peoples" also eliminated problems, as he himself thought.

Shootings and camps have spread so much that no one was surprised anymore. And the terms of imprisonment are simply amazing - an average of 25 years. There was no question of any freedom of speech. But the worst thing is what was encouraged as a civil consciousness: denunciation and slander. A friend could write a denunciation against a friend, a neighbor - against a neighbor. An atmosphere of distrust and suspicion reigned. It is strange that in such a gloomy reality, people managed to somehow live, love, build families and raise children.

So who said that?

All of the above characterizes comrade Dzhugashvili as a tyrant, a despot, not quite an adequate person, appointed by fate to the post of leader. The fact that Joseph Stalin literally physically destroyed his people speaks of the high probability of his authorship of the catchphrase.

So who said: "No person - no problem"? Let's be honest, the "leader of the peoples" could say it, it was in his manner. Like no one else, he would have dared to speak such words with impunity, based on historical facts. Which is not true as no one has been able to prove it.

Rybakov. Children of the Arbat

No matter how cruel "comrade Stalin" was, at the same time he was cautious and cunning as a politician. He did not consider it right to openly declare his bloody plans. But still there is a solution to the riddle, who owns the statement "There is a person - there is a problem, no person - there is no problem."

The famous Soviet writer Anatoly Naumovich Rybakov created the novel "Children of the Arbat", which was published in 1987. With the "light hand" of the writer, the catchphrase was put into the mouth of the leader. It was in this work that Stalin said: "Death solves all problems. There is no person, and there is no problem." The work de alt with the execution in the town of Tsaritsyn (in 1918) of military specialists.

The famous expression so fit into the appearance of Dzhugashvili himself that the reader did not doubt the authenticity of the historical moment in the slightest. Although this fact is entirely a fiction of the author of the novel - Rybakov.

Author's acknowledgment

Rybakov himself wondered why the popular expression is attributed to Joseph Stalin. He drew attention to the popularity of this phrase, this fact even upset the author a little. Why, after all, it was Rybakov who came up with the catch phrase! And in one of his conversations with journalist Valery Lebedev, Anatoly Naumovich admitted the fact that he wrote the phrase "no man - no problem" in the novel "Children of the Arbat". First, he tried to ask the journalist: where did Stalin say this, in what year, in which of his speeches? There were no answers to these questions.

If the catchphrase has gone to the people, then this does credit to the author! Later, in 1997, Rybakov admitted in "Roman-Memories" that he invented the statement "no man - no problem" on his own. And Anatoly did itNaumovich because that's how he felt his hero. He intuitively felt how the leader could build a thought and what turns of speech are characteristic of him. Historically, the writer was not mistaken. The cruel phrase took root and became a kind of symbol of the "Stalinist winter".

The popularity of the novel

A. Rybakov's novel "Children of the Arbat" caused a sensation and became very popular. It is the history of this work that answers the question of who said: "no man - no problem." And also the novel explains the meaning of this popular expression. He made a lot of noise in the press and turned the minds of his readers. During these years, many historical events were rethought.

The novel tells about the difficult fate of people born and growing up in the 30s. Reveals the whole truth about the Stalinist totalitarian regime. In the work, the author tries to figure out how this terrible machine worked, he shows all this using examples of human destinies. The mechanism for solving political "problems" was launched by the Stalin regime and destroyed people literally, in the physical sense.

Time cover

Time magazine featured "Comrade Stalin" on its cover several times. Twice the portrait of the leader was placed on the cover as "person of the year". Opponents of the "cult of personality" have repeatedly written about the existence of one of them, which allegedly depicted Stalin and wrote the famous saying: "No man - no problems." There it was aboutcollectivization. This happened in February 1993. This cover just acted as evidence that the phrase belonged to Stalin.

In fact, there is no such cover. Her image, which walks on the Internet, is a common fake. You can also find the actual cover image of Time Magazine (February 6, 1933 issue).

And why was the fake created? There is no definite answer to this question. It seems that Stalin's opponents so zealously wanted to ascribe to him the famous aphorism that they took this step. Like, there is a real source that you can always refer to, confirm the truth of the phrase belonging to Joseph Vissarionovich Stalin.

It should be concluded that it is time to stop arguing about whose words: "no person - no problem." The main thing is that the meaning of this expression is unambiguous, its meaning is clear to any person.